One-click walls

Any good player knows that to succeed in this game, you must wall your cities. The problem is that any game involving large areas requires lots of time building walls. Time yourself. Don't be surprised if you spend a third of your time building walls. Now imagine if you had the option to buy a defense ring with one click. Games would run faster, new players would fare better, our hands wouldn't get so tired, and we could focus on the reason we like this game: strategy.

No walling skills are a part of the game

Time management is a skill in it's own right.

Making walls is a part of strategy (aka time management), you have to prioritize what you want to do. Do you want to invest 1mins/2mins walling in quick games, or spend 30sec/2mins walling while investing the rest of the time in an offensive expansion/tb's. Making walling easier than it already (with the use of hotkeys) just destroys the strategy aspect of walling all together. I agree with your reasons that newer players would be better and less tired hands, but this would reduce skill gap which is never good in a strategy game.

נכתב על ידי Longarm, 24.05.2016 at 17:10

. Now imagine if you had the option to buy a defense ring with one click. Games would run faster, new players would fare better, our hands wouldn't get so tired.

As an advanced option I it could be included therefore not impacting on the game META overall. I can see the benefits for new players also.

Every wall walled the same would be daft. We can't counter a wf that way or place it further from the enemy so, they can't reach it.

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 24.05.2016 at 18:14

נכתב על ידי Longarm, 24.05.2016 at 17:10

. Now imagine if you had the option to buy a defense ring with one click. Games would run faster, new players would fare better, our hands wouldn't get so tired.

As an option I it could be included therefore not impacting on the game META overall. I can see the benefits for new players also.

No sun please adding auto wall feature would be just bad.

נכתב על ידי Longarm, 24.05.2016 at 17:10

Any good player knows that to succeed in this game, you must wall your cities. The problem is that any game involving large areas requires lots of time building walls. Time yourself. Don't be surprised if you spend a third of your time building walls. Now imagine if you had the option to buy a defense ring with one click. Games would run faster, new players would fare better, our hands wouldn't get so tired, and we could focus on the reason we like this game: strategy.

You should use the shortcuts

נכתב על ידי Nations, 25.05.2016 at 04:47

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 24.05.2016 at 18:14

נכתב על ידי Longarm, 24.05.2016 at 17:10

. Now imagine if you had the option to buy a defense ring with one click. Games would run faster, new players would fare better, our hands wouldn't get so tired.

As an option I it could be included therefore not impacting on the game META overall. I can see the benefits for new players also.

No sun please adding auto wall feature would be just bad.

It has advantageous and disadvantageous

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 07:18

נכתב על ידי Nations, 25.05.2016 at 04:47

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 24.05.2016 at 18:14

נכתב על ידי Longarm, 24.05.2016 at 17:10

. Now imagine if you had the option to buy a defense ring with one click. Games would run faster, new players would fare better, our hands wouldn't get so tired.

As an option I it could be included therefore not impacting on the game META overall. I can see the benefits for new players also.

No sun please adding auto wall feature would be just bad.

It has advantageous and disadvantageous

well i dont get why an idea why no support from community you want to improvise it so badly.

נכתב על ידי Nations, 25.05.2016 at 07:20

well i dont get why an idea why no support from community you want to improvise it so badly.

Because typically players think about how they can improve the game for themselves and not for noobs. It is human nature to propagate self interest first.

Most important and greatest game mechanic, one that can decide games... and you would want to turn it into one-click-crap

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 07:22

נכתב על ידי Nations, 25.05.2016 at 07:20

well i dont get why an idea why no support from community you want to improvise it so badly.

Because typically players think about how they can improve the game for themselves and not for noobs. It is human nature to propagate self interest first.

you sound like a dictator

נכתב על ידי Goblin, 25.05.2016 at 08:31

Most important and greatest game mechanic, one that can decide games... and you would want to turn it into one-click-crap

But you wouldn't need to enable this should you not wish for it, and will make the game considerably easier for newer/lazy players.- not every player has abundant amounts of time to practice making walls in under 5 seconds also.

נכתב על ידי Nations, 25.05.2016 at 10:28

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 07:22

נכתב על ידי Nations, 25.05.2016 at 07:20

well i dont get why an idea why no support from community you want to improvise it so badly.

Because typically players think about how they can improve the game for themselves and not for noobs. It is human nature to propagate self interest first.

you sound like a dictator

Or maybe a marketing administrator on a computer game, oh wait! and you are pointlessly quoting me why?

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 12:11

not every player has abundant amounts of time to practice making walls in under 5 seconds also.

Then play turn times more adjusted to your skill level... and competitive players who are able to do all their moves and walls and still have time to chat should play lower turn times

#3minCW

נכתב על ידי Goblin, 25.05.2016 at 12:43

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 12:11

not every player has abundant amounts of time to practice making walls in under 5 seconds also.

Then play turn times more adjusted to your skill level... and competitive players who are able to do all their moves and walls and still have time to chat should play lower turn times

#3minCW

For instance, this would be useful for players that can/want to play the game for an hour a week, unfortunately a lot of players aren't able or wont commit to longer turn times/casual games, players which fall into the category are the players the game has the best opportunity to monetise, busy working people. I get why your against it I really do, I used to be too, also the type of players I am discussing I assume don't regularly check the forum, however I do receive complaints from players who cannot adjust to the main room and find the initial learning curve/skill disparity too much to deal with and leave.

It takes 3 sec to wall a city with the shortcuts, so why do we need a scripted wall?

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 07:22

נכתב על ידי Nations, 25.05.2016 at 07:20

well i dont get why an idea why no support from community you want to improvise it so badly.

Because typically players think about how they can improve the game for themselves and not for noobs. It is human nature to propagate self interest first.

honestly new players will never learn to wall if they have an option to do it auto wall just like they never learn to manage funds since they can play rp games...

<Read what gow said> and if you are slow, you should play casual games. Endless time to play a turn.

נכתב על ידי 1GodofWar1, 25.05.2016 at 13:59

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 07:22

נכתב על ידי Nations, 25.05.2016 at 07:20

well i dont get why an idea why no support from community you want to improvise it so badly.

Because typically players think about how they can improve the game for themselves and not for noobs. It is human nature to propagate self interest first.

honestly new players will never learn to wall if they have an option to do it auto wall just like they never learn to manage funds since they can play rp games...

The majority of atWar doesnt play RP or high money games, most players play scenarios or low money games, RP/UN has existed ever since we have had 50k games, and still the low level money setting is thriving, especially in 1v1 duels with more players than ever choosing this, therefore in my opinion not a reasonable comparison. Most players who would enable this setting, you would never come into contact with anyway.

נכתב על ידי Guest, 25.05.2016 at 15:07

<Read what gow said> and if you are slow, you should play casual games. Endless time to play a turn.

Many players can't commit to the 48 hour time limit, I have asked to extend it to 7 day turns, however that is considered to long for turns, therefore playing casual games doesn't solve anything - and for some casual players tediously walling over 100 cities is boring

נכתב על ידי Lemonade, 25.05.2016 at 13:32

It takes 3 sec to wall a city with the shortcuts, so why do we need a scripted wall?

It isn't so easy for noobs, even with the shortcuts.

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 15:50

A "no wall" setting would serve better in my opinion since it is something higher ranks want to, and lower ranks can use it to make and make turns quicker to get more playtime in. This way it would be a win-win for everyone. If lower ranks want to learn to wall they can, or they can just use this setting for casual play.

What this proposes it almost like a see through walls for a 5 sec at a time in a FPS, sure the player has to still use hand eye coordination - but it takes away from the strategy/meta game as a whole. You would see almost ever city being walled in atWar than we would have a new problem (which people do not realise would happen). "Now I have to spend too much time wf cities, please find us a solution".

Due to these reasons I feel the "no wall" setting is the best option.

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 15:50

נכתב על ידי Lemonade, 25.05.2016 at 13:32

It takes 3 sec to wall a city with the shortcuts, so why do we need a scripted wall?

It isn't so easy for noobs, even with the shortcuts.

Give us no wall games as option, shouldnt be to hard to implement, new part of ATWAR------------ NWG-no wall games

נכתב על ידי MURAD IV, 25.05.2016 at 16:25

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 15:50

נכתב על ידי Lemonade, 25.05.2016 at 13:32

It takes 3 sec to wall a city with the shortcuts, so why do we need a scripted wall?

It isn't so easy for noobs, even with the shortcuts.

Give us no wall games as option, shouldnt be to hard to implement, new part of ATWAR------------ NWG-no wall games

No Wall sucks, a "better tutorial" (how to use shortcuts) would be better

Walling isnt a skill, its a basic movement that everyone does, but it doesnt require skill...like...at all

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 15:50

נכתב על ידי Lemonade, 25.05.2016 at 13:32

It takes 3 sec to wall a city with the shortcuts, so why do we need a scripted wall?

It isn't so easy for noobs, even with the shortcuts.

Which means that they'll never learn how to make a proper wall. And the second the 'one click to wall' feature gets bugged and stops working, forum and help chat will be flooded with 'HALP I can't wall, so I die. Pliss fix'

נכתב על ידי Lemonade, 25.05.2016 at 16:36

נכתב על ידי MURAD IV, 25.05.2016 at 16:25

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 25.05.2016 at 15:50

נכתב על ידי Lemonade, 25.05.2016 at 13:32

It takes 3 sec to wall a city with the shortcuts, so why do we need a scripted wall?

It isn't so easy for noobs, even with the shortcuts.

Give us no wall games as option, shouldnt be to hard to implement, new part of ATWAR------------ NWG-no wall games

No Wall sucks, a "better tutorial" (how to use shortcuts) would be better

Ok,making auto-walls is out of the question.

As many have said it is time management and skill.

Now if new players learn how to wall,but it isn't easy for them then they shouldn't play this game.I mean you gonna play a strategic game and you don't have iq required to form a wall quickly?

Anyway what troll said is the best,add in the tutioral how to wall and maybe add a game player who will auto wall a city near the new player and tell him to wall/wf it.

It will be like:"To continue wall Berlin,capital of Germany and wf munich"

Ideas?

We are already covering every aspect of walling in a new tutorial.

נכתב על ידי Darth., 25.05.2016 at 23:38

Which means that they'll never learn how to make a proper wall. And the second the 'one click to wall' feature gets bugged and stops working, forum and help chat will be flooded with 'HALP I can't wall, so I die. Pliss fix'

Thats right they may never learn how to wall properly with this proposal, that is the point they would never have time to anyway and leave the game in the alternative. And you cannot use a bug that doesn't even exist as an argument. Just becuase we have a highmoney setting doesn't mean players only choose high money games. It would be an option that wouldn't affect about 90% of the game anyway.