AtWar players preferred clan war system

Following on from the previous poll I made, The results showed that around 80% of players wanted to see a completely new clan war system, not conclusive by any means as the results were counted at only 35 votes, the fact that only one person (opi ) voted to keep the current system must hint at something.



Therefore I have compiled as many topics as I can find relating to ideas for a new system, to give the community a voice to show which idea is most popular.. Please read the ideas before voting:

• Desu update 2.0
• Coalition Elo
• Draconi 1.1
• Lord Pontez 1.0
• Silent One 1.0

Thoughts are welcome to promote a particular idea. Also if I have missed an idea, please be sure to let me know. Cheers.

Desus idea basically is coalition elo.

POntez idea, simpel. but give like 75 max cp not just 50 each time.

נכתב על ידי Permamuted, 02.02.2015 at 09:25

Desus idea basically is coalition elo.

I see your point, though slightly different to the version spart published, hence the different titles.

Bla bla bla just make league and gg

נכתב על ידי Ferlucci1389, 02.02.2015 at 11:21

Bla bla bla just make league and gg

i agree a league would be better, unfortunately the idea seems to lack support from other players. The other ideas are popular as it provides the same flexibility and to set fixtures is another question, look how difficult it is to get teams to play in the prem tourney. Also it would restrict the number of games played. I think with 10 active cw clans it's about time the community created its own league regardless

What if we want to vote for Draconi's further suggestions part?

נכתב על ידי cascaval, 02.02.2015 at 12:18

What if we want to vote for Draconi's further suggestions part?

I do not know, I wasn't able to create branches from the poll.

נכתב על ידי Ferlucci1389, 02.02.2015 at 11:21

Bla bla bla just make league and gg

Can you elaborate on this?

Regardless of clan war pints and all (cuz i know ivan and amok wont changed it ) we should make league all clan who sigh up we make table and 4 rounds 2 home 2 away (when u are home team u get 1 pick ,u get 2 points for win and 1 point for loss like in basketball it is only fair thing to do and to see who is best once and for all ,we could reset it every season so we have new League every season.

Cw system does not need change it is fine the way it is

נכתב על ידי Ferlucci1389, 02.02.2015 at 11:21

Bla bla bla just make league and gg

LOL YES. SUPPORT MY BIG MAN

נכתב על ידי chill, 02.02.2015 at 14:55

Cw system does not need change it is fine the way it is

lol

נכתב על ידי Ferlucci1389, 02.02.2015 at 14:49

Regardless of clan war pints and all (cuz i know ivan and amok wont changed it ) we should make league all clan who sigh up we make table and 4 rounds 2 home 2 away (when u are home team u get 1 pick ,u get 2 points for win and 1 point for loss like in basketball it is only fair thing to do and to see who is best once and for all ,we could reset it every season so we have new League every season.

Shitty idea. Has been tried and always fails. Please go kill self. Thanks. Kbye

Good polls

(shouldn't this be in general discussion forums? )

I really think 20 game per season was the best...low comp clns r stopping cwing after reaching the top its really unfair for the regular cwing clns

נכתב על ידי clovis1122, 02.02.2015 at 21:11

Good polls

(shouldn't this be in general discussion forums? )

I

Thnx Clovis,

Clovis: (shouldn't this be in general discussion forums? )
Sun Tzu: idk

נכתב על ידי Skills., 03.02.2015 at 04:22

I really think 20 game per season was the best...low comp clns r stopping cwing after reaching the top its really unfair for the regular cwing clns

Its the same problem now as when we had 20games.

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 03.02.2015 at 04:50

נכתב על ידי Skills., 03.02.2015 at 04:22

I really think 20 game per season was the best...low comp clns r stopping cwing after reaching the top its really unfair for the regular cwing clns

We had same problem as we have now when we had 20games.

bt it was way more less then nowadays low comp clns used to hav 600+ max now thy hav 1100 1200+

נכתב על ידי Skills., 03.02.2015 at 04:53

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 03.02.2015 at 04:50

נכתב על ידי Skills., 03.02.2015 at 04:22

I really think 20 game per season was the best...low comp clns r stopping cwing after reaching the top its really unfair for the regular cwing clns

We had same problem as we have now when we had 20games.

bt it was way more less then nowadays low comp clns used to hav 600+ max now thy hav 1100 1200+

This system rewards inactivity and discourages activity when a clan reaches certain amount of points regardless of the number of games counted. A clan can win their first 10 games, lose next 15 games and win next 5 games and those first 10 wins count for nothing apart from to build a clans competence which only goes against clans when calculating points. With so many more active clans, the current system is no longer fit for purpose especially with some clans playing 100+ games in a season.

Desu Update 2.0

Coalition elo - definitely best option

http://prntscr.com/69hghe it seems like we have a result

נכתב על ידי Sun Tsu, 24.02.2015 at 19:22

http://prntscr.com/69hghe it seems like we have a result

Sounds good for me. Will see how it is going to work

I like Draconi's and Coalition elo solutions.. And Lord's idea about 2 trophy sistem (Cup and League) is good..

Silent One (1.0) best

''Starting from this season Coalitions will be ranked by Elo rating, currently used in duels. There will be an overall Elo and seasonal Elo, which will be reset to 1000 in the beginning of every season. Seasonal Elo will be introduced for duels as well, with top 3 players receiving special trophies.''- atWar fb page